If you hunt
doves, you've likely fielded some grief from non-hunters about it. And if you're someone who doesn't think people should hunt doves, it's likely rooted in a feeling that songbirds should be off limits.
But William Hornaday, a leading antagonist of dove hunting more than a century ago, made arguments against dove hunting laced with bigotry, attacking Italians for
shooting “everything that wear feathers” and bemoaning that “in the South, the negroes and poor whites are killing song-birds, woodpeckers and doves for food.”
To which we say, um, yeah, food is a pretty solid reason to hunt. Let's not confuse subsistence hunting with the obscene overkill of market hunting.
Hornaday, a wealthy New Yorker, rightly fought market hunting as well, for which he deserves credit. But it's worth knowing that the origins of distaste for dove hunting might be more about the people who were hunting doves than about the appropriateness of the gamebirds themselves.
Hank writes more about this in a free post on To The Bone.